Cocktail Menu
Cocktails, Wine & Beer
Happy Hour Menu
Monday - Thursday 4-6PMHappy Hour Cocktails
All $14-
Bin 'n' Gitters
GIN, FRESH LIME JUICE, SIMPLE SYRUP AND ANGOSTURA BITTERS. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE WITH A LIME WEDGE AND A CHERRY ON TOP. Adapted from “The South American Gentleman's Companion, Being an Exotic Drinking Book OR Up & Down the Andes with Jigger, Beaker & Flask” by Charles H. Baker, Jr., 1951
-
Dorado Delicioso
GIN, FRESH LIME JUICE, SUGAR, ANGOSTURA BITTERS. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. Adapted from ‘The South American Gentleman's Companion, Being an Exotic Drinking Book Or, Up & Down the Andes with Jigger, Beaker & Flask’ by Charles H. Baker, Jr., 1951
-
Caperol Spritz
APEROL, APERITIVO CAPPELLETTI, WHITE WINE AND CITRUS CORDIAL, SODA. SERVED LONG. In appreciation of the legendary aperitivo cocktail from Padova, Italia, circa 1950’s
-
Bermuda Swizzle
BERMUDA RUM, FALERNUM, FRESH JUICES OF PINEAPPLE AND LIME, SUGAR, ANGOSTURA BITTERS. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. Adapted from a cocktail made at the Swizzle Inn on Bailey's Bay, Bermuda circa 1932
Best of Both Worlds
Choice beer and shot pairings form our distinguished well. All $12-
Miller High Life & Rye or Bourbon
-
Modelo Especial & Tequila
-
Red Stripe & Aged Rum
Bottles & Cans
-
Utica Club
$4 -
Miller High Life
$4 -
Modelo Negra
$4 -
Modelo Especial
$4 -
Red Stripe
$4
Draft Beer
-
The Gem's Lakeside Lager Brewed by Other Half
$6 -
Common Roots IPA
$7
Cocktails
SPRING/SUMMER 2026-
1887 Manhattan
RYE WHISKEY, SWEET VERMOUTH, ORANGE CURAÇAO, ANGOSTURA BITTERS. STIRRED AND SERVED STRAIGHT UP. Adapted from The Bon-Vivant's Companion by Jerry Thomas, circa 1862
-
American Trilogy
RYE WHISKEY, BONDED APPLEJACK, DEMERARA SUGAR, ORANGE BITTERS. BUILT IN THE GLASS ON A ROCK WITH AN ORANGE TWIST. By Richard Boccato at Little Branch NYC, circa 2007
-
Night Moves
RYE WHISKEY, AQUAVIT, PUNT E MES, PASSION FRUIT, FRESH LEMON JUICE, CINNAMON, NUTMEG. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. By Graham Christie at The Gem, 2026
-
Millionaire Punch
BOURBON, CRÈME DE MENTHE, HOUSE-MADE GRENADINE, FRESH LEMON JUICE, SODA WATER. SERVED LONG. Adapted From "Here's How” by The Three Mountaineers, circa 1939
-
Problem Solver
BLANCO TEQUILA, AMARO MONTENEGRO, RASPBERRY, FRESH LEMON JUICE, CUCUMBER. SHAKEN AND SERVED DOWN. By Jay Manrique at The Gem, 2026
-
Game of Death
REPOSADO TEQUILA, AMARO MELETTI, SUGAR, FRESH JUICES OF GRAPEFRUIT AND LIME, SODA WATER. SERVED LONG WITH *SAL DE CHAPULÍN. By Richard Boccato & Matty Clark at Dutch Kills NYC circa 2016
-
Tinderbox
MEZCAL, APRICOT LIQUEUR, CINNAMON, FRESH LIME JUICE, HABANERO BITTERS. SHAKEN AND SERVED STRAIGHT UP. By Jason Kilgore at Dutch Kills NYC, 2025
-
Queen's Park Swizzle
AGED RUM, FRESH LIME JUICE, DEMERARA, MINT, ANGOSTURA BITTERS. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. By Victor “Trader Vic” Bergeron, circa 1932
Deluxe Cocktails
...an homage to Dutch Kills, our sister bar in Queens, NYC.-
Painkiller
$20PLANTERAY XO 20TH ANNIVERSARY RUM, PLANTERAY SPECIAL RELEASE SEALANDER RUM, FRESH JUICES OF PINEAPPLE AND ORANGE, COCONUT, NUTMEG, CINNAMON. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. Adapted from Daphne Henderson or George and Marie Myrick at the Soggy Dollar Bar on the Island of Jost Can Dyke, BVI, circa 1971
-
Vesper Martini
$20BROOKLYN GIN, TITO'S VODKA, COCCHI AMERICANO. STIRRED AND SERVED STRAIGHT UP WITH CAVIAR ON THE SIDE. Adapted from a recipe written by Ian Fleming for James Bond in the 1953 novel ‘Casino Royale’.
Featured American Whiskey
...an homage to Wm. Farmer and Sons, our sister restaurant in Hudson, NY.-
Ask your server about our rotating selection.
Neat or On the Rocks $17
As a Manhattan or Old Fashioned $20
Draft Beer
All $9-
Common Roots IPA
-
The Gem's Lakeside Lager Brewed by Other Half
-
Ask your server about our rotating selection.
Bottles & Cans
-
Miller High Life
$5 -
Utica Club
$5 -
Red Stripe
$5 -
Especial Modelo
$5 -
Modelo Negra
$5 -
Nine Pin Cider
$7 -
Athletic Brewing Co. N.A. Golden Ale
$7 -
Athletic Brewing Co. Run Wild N.A. IPA
$7 -
Dogfishhead Sour
$7
Best of Both Worlds
Choice beer and shot pairings from our distinguished well. All $13-
Dogfishhead Sea Quench Ale & Mezcal
-
Miller High Life & Rye or Bourbon
-
Modelo Especial & Blanco Tequila
-
Modelo Negra & Reposado Tequila
-
Red Stripe & Aged Rum
Tap Cocktails
-
Caperol Spritz
APEROL, APERITIVO CAPPELLETTI, WHITE WINE AND CITRUS CORDIAL, SODA. SERVED LONG. In appreciation of the legendary aperitivo cocktail from Padova, Italia, circa 1950’s
-
New York Sour
BOURBON, CITRUS CORDIAL, RED WINE FLOAT. SERVED ON CRUSHED ICE. Adapted from "Jones' Bar Guide" by Stan Jones, circa 1977
Frozen Cocktails
-
Frozen Willy's Way
HOUSE-MADE GRENADINE, FRESH LIME JUICE. *MAKE IT A WILLY’S GÜEY (WITH TEQUILA)
-
Frozen Tommy's Margarita
BLANCO TEQUILA, FRESH LIME JUICE, AGAVE. SERVED WITH *SAL DE GUSANO. By Julio Bermejo, Tommy's Restaurant, San Francisco, circa 1990
-
Frozen Ramos Gin Fizz
OLD TOM GIN, FRESH JUICES OF LEMON AND LIME, ORANGE FLOWER WATER, DEMERARA, HEAVY CREAM, HOUSE-MADE CHARCOAL SALT, EGG WHITE. By Henry C. Ramos at the Imperial Cabinet Saloon in New Orleans, Louisiana, 1888
-
Frozen Irish Coffee
IRISH WHISKEY, LICOR 43, COLD BREW, COCONUT, HONEY. Adapted from the original recipe by Jim Monaghan at Molly's at the Market in New Orleans, Louisiana, circa 1980's
-
Frozen Mojito
AGED RUM, FRESH LIME JUICE, DEMERARA, MINT.
Dessert Cocktails
-
Espresso Martini
VODKA, ESPRESSO LIQUEUR, COLD BREW, CINNAMON. SHAKEN AND SERVED STRAIGHT UP. Adapted from the original recipe by Dick Bradsell at Soho Brasserie, London, UK, circa 1983
-
Tiger Chilled Coffee
JAMAICAN RUM, DARK RUM, ALLSPICE, COLD BREW, CINNAMON, SWEET WHIPPED CREAM, ABSINTHE. BUILT IN THE GLASS ON A ROCK. By Matty Clark at Dutch Kills NYC, 2014
-
Bee's Kiss
AGED RUM, HONEY, HEAVY CREAM. SHAKEN AND SERVED STRAIGHT UP. By Sasha Petraske at Milk & Honey NYC, circa 2000
Wine
White
-
Gruner
WEINGUT BERGER, 2023 - NIEDEROSTERREICH, AUSTRIA
Glass $10
Bottle $38
-
Sauvignon Blanc
TOPETTE, 2023 - LOIRE VALLEY, FRANCE
Glass $13
Bottle $46
-
Albariño
VAL DE MEIGAS 2025 - RÍAS BAIXAS, GALICIA, SPAIN
Glass $11
Bottle $40
-
Chardonnay
THE ARSONIST, 2023 - CENTRAL VALLEY, CALIFORNIA, USA
Glass $13
Bottle $46
-
Orange
SAUVIGNON BLANC / VERDEJO, GULP HABLO, 2024 - CASTILLA-LA MANCHA, SPAIN
Glass $11
Bottle $40
-
Rosé
BONNY DOON VINYARD, 2025 - SANTA CRUZ, CALIFORNIA, USA
Glass $11
Bottle $40
Red
-
Chilled Red
BADIA A COLTIBOUNO, 2025 - TOSCANA, ITALY
Glass $12
Bottle $46
-
Pinot Noir
PAS DE PROBLEME, 2024 - LOIRE VALLEY, FRANCE
Glass $11
Bottle $46
-
Cabernet
MATTHEW FRITZ - SONOMA, CALIFORNIA, USA
Glass $13
Bottle $50
Bubbles
-
Prosecco
Bianca Vigna Brut - Conegliao, Italia
Glass $10
Bottle $42
-
Champagne
GASTON-CHIQUET, CHAMPAGNE, FRANCE
Half Bottle $46
Bottle $70
Amari Di Italia
All $8-
Alta Verde
Trentino
-
Averna
Sicilia
-
Amaro Nardini
Bassano
-
Cio Ciaro
Ciociaria
-
Cynar
Milano
-
Fernet Branca
Milano
-
Montenegro
Bologna
-
Meletti
Le Marche
Digestivi
-
Bigallet China-China
$12Loire, France
-
Genepy Herbetet
$10Valle D’Aosta, Italia
Absinthe
-
St. George
$10Alameda, Ca, Usa